Lewis Pullman William Lee Jonas Lauenstein / Fabian Oscar Wien Amanda Seyfried Ann Lee Magdalena Turba / Magdalena Turba / Magdalena Turba Viola Prettejohn Nancy Lee Paulina Rümmelein / Magdalena Montasser Tim Blake Nelson Pastor Reuben Wright Timmo Niesner / Tobias Lelle Natalie Shinnick Elizabeth Hale Julia Bautz Christopher Abbott Abraham Standerin Tim Knauer / Florian Clyde Thomasin McKenzie Mary Partington Léa Mariage / Léa Mariage Matthew Beard James Whittaker Hannes Maurer / Daniel Schlauch Stacy Martin Jane Wardley Lena Schmidtke / Laura Oettel David Cale John Hocknell Udo Wachtveitl Matti Boustedt Captain Smith Dietmar Wunder Roy McCrerey Mr. Shattuck Tom Vogt Alexis Latham Mr. Cunningham Frank Röth Shannon Woodward Mrs. Cunningham Shandra Schadt Scott Alexander Young Tideswell K.Dieter Klebsch